By By: Alphanso G. Kalama;
Monrovia, Liberia – A newly released medical report from ELWA Hospital has contradicted claims that Chinese businessman Michael Shio tortured Liberian national Momoh David by pouring hot oil on him. The report, submitted to the Monrovia City Court in response to a subpoena, indicates that David’s burns were caused by fire rather than hot oil, raising serious concerns about the initial allegations.
According to the hospital’s findings, David, 26, was admitted to ELWA Hospital on January 17, 2025, with partial-thickness burns covering approximately 23% of his body. The burns affected his face, neck, upper limbs, and torso. The report clarifies that the injuries were caused by fire and occurred roughly 24 hours before he sought medical attention, placing the incident on January 16 not January 13 as previously alleged.
This medical assessment challenges the accusations against Shio, which were widely publicized by the Liberia Broadcasting System (LBS) under its Director General, Eugene L. Fahngon. Reports suggest that LBS lifted the story directly from Momoh David’s family without conducting proper journalistic verification. The state broadcaster then disseminated the claims both on national media and social media, fueling widespread outrage.
A handwritten note from Joyce Teta Teage, dated February 9, 2025, describes how she was initially informed of David’s death but later discovered he was still alive. She claims David told her that a “Chinese man” attacked him for allegedly stealing from his compound. However, the ELWA medical report presents a different picture, raising questions about the credibility of the accusations.
The report states that David received immediate medical care, including tetanus anti-toxin, resuscitation fluids, and pain medication, followed by routine dressing changes and infection prevention measures. He remained in the hospital for 14 days and was discharged on February 1, 2025, showing signs of healing. The long-term impact of his injuries remains uncertain, with doctors stating that complications could be either temporary or permanent.
With these conflicting narratives, the credibility of LBS and its leadership has come under scrutiny. Critics question whether Fahngon’s decision to air the unverified claims was an error in journalistic judgment or driven by an underlying motive. The implications for the state broadcaster are significant, as spreading misinformation on such a sensitive matter could undermine public trust in the institution.
Legal experts suggest that the Monrovia City Court may now have to reassess the basis of the claims against Shio in light of this new medical documentation. Additionally, there are growing calls for an internal review within LBS to ensure accountability in its reporting practices.
As the investigation continues, authorities must determine the exact circumstances leading to David’s injuries. Meanwhile, ELWA Hospital’s records serve as a crucial piece of evidence in the ongoing legal proceedings, potentially altering the course of the case entirely.
